Accendo Reliability

Your Reliability Engineering Professional Development Site

  • Home
  • About
    • Contributors
  • Reliability.fm
    • Speaking Of Reliability
    • Rooted in Reliability: The Plant Performance Podcast
    • Quality during Design
    • Way of the Quality Warrior
    • Critical Talks
    • Dare to Know
    • Maintenance Disrupted
    • Metal Conversations
    • The Leadership Connection
    • Practical Reliability Podcast
    • Reliability Matters
    • Reliability it Matters
    • Maintenance Mavericks Podcast
    • Women in Maintenance
    • Accendo Reliability Webinar Series
  • Articles
    • CRE Preparation Notes
    • on Leadership & Career
      • Advanced Engineering Culture
      • Engineering Leadership
      • Managing in the 2000s
      • Product Development and Process Improvement
    • on Maintenance Reliability
      • Aasan Asset Management
      • AI & Predictive Maintenance
      • Asset Management in the Mining Industry
      • CMMS and Reliability
      • Conscious Asset
      • EAM & CMMS
      • Everyday RCM
      • History of Maintenance Management
      • Life Cycle Asset Management
      • Maintenance and Reliability
      • Maintenance Management
      • Plant Maintenance
      • Process Plant Reliability Engineering
      • ReliabilityXperience
      • RCM Blitz®
      • Rob’s Reliability Project
      • The Intelligent Transformer Blog
      • The People Side of Maintenance
      • The Reliability Mindset
    • on Product Reliability
      • Accelerated Reliability
      • Achieving the Benefits of Reliability
      • Apex Ridge
      • Metals Engineering and Product Reliability
      • Musings on Reliability and Maintenance Topics
      • Product Validation
      • Reliability Engineering Insights
      • Reliability in Emerging Technology
    • on Risk & Safety
      • CERM® Risk Insights
      • Equipment Risk and Reliability in Downhole Applications
      • Operational Risk Process Safety
    • on Systems Thinking
      • Communicating with FINESSE
      • The RCA
    • on Tools & Techniques
      • Big Data & Analytics
      • Experimental Design for NPD
      • Innovative Thinking in Reliability and Durability
      • Inside and Beyond HALT
      • Inside FMEA
      • Integral Concepts
      • Learning from Failures
      • Progress in Field Reliability?
      • R for Engineering
      • Reliability Engineering Using Python
      • Reliability Reflections
      • Testing 1 2 3
      • The Manufacturing Academy
  • eBooks
  • Resources
    • Accendo Authors
    • FMEA Resources
    • Feed Forward Publications
    • Openings
    • Books
    • Webinars
    • Journals
    • Higher Education
    • Podcasts
  • Courses
    • 14 Ways to Acquire Reliability Engineering Knowledge
    • Reliability Analysis Methods online course
    • Measurement System Assessment
    • SPC-Process Capability Course
    • Design of Experiments
    • Foundations of RCM online course
    • Quality during Design Journey
    • Reliability Engineering Statistics
    • Quality Engineering Statistics
    • An Introduction to Reliability Engineering
    • Reliability Engineering for Heavy Industry
    • An Introduction to Quality Engineering
    • Process Capability Analysis course
    • Root Cause Analysis and the 8D Corrective Action Process course
    • Return on Investment online course
    • CRE Preparation Online Course
    • Quondam Courses
  • Webinars
    • Upcoming Live Events
  • Calendar
    • Call for Papers Listing
    • Upcoming Webinars
    • Webinar Calendar
  • Login
    • Member Home

by nomtbf Leave a Comment

3 Recent Questions and Comments Concerning MTBF

3 Recent Questions and Comments Concerning MTBF

Trying to Respond to All Questions and Comments Concerning MTBF

Over the past couple of days, like most days, have received questions and comments concerning MTBF. I do try to respond to all questions and acknowledge the comments.

Glad to help in anyway I can, so please feel free to send me your questions. Certainly do appreciate the supporting comments, or any comments for that matter.

Let’s take a look a few such discussion that occurred over the past two days.

Which Parts Count Method to Use Today?

The question:

Hi

I have a basic question and request you to clarify. Which method should i follow ( MIL 217 F or Telcordia) for MTBF and Failure rate calculations for Automotive application electronics part.

Thanks in advance !!

Regards,

My response:

Neither – 217 is little more than a random number generator and is over 20 years old based on data and technology the is even older.

Telcordia is likewise little more than a random number generator concerning the expected future reliability performance, and based on telecommunication system failure data. Not suitable for automotive applications at all.

If you are simply comparing design options and not attempting to estimate future reliability field performance then use your own field data supplemented with vendor or internal testing data.

If trying to estimate field performance, parts count predictions is not the right tool.

Cheers, Fred


So, was the an appropriate response or was I bit too harsh?


Directed to Calculate MTBF

Hello Fred,
How are you and hope this email meets you well.
Please I have a question concerning MTBF.
Our international reliability department just sent us an updated memo for calculating MTBF for both operational units and standby units.
I do not agree with their calculation because they divide the number of hours by the total number of failures.
Please what do you think?
Thanks for your help.
Kind regards,
My response:

HI … ,

First the reliability department should know better than to use MTBF at all. My opinion is MTBF is a very poor measure, and only measures the average of the inverse failure rate, thus providing very little useful information. It is often mis-used and mis-understood, too. See nomtbf.com for many more reasons to avoid using MTBF.
Second, the total hours divided by total number of failures is a common way to calculate MTBF.
Third, using MTBF for your situation is most likely not helpful. If you have to report to this department, send them both MTBF and a Weibull Plot or reliability over a duration that is meaningful. Send both, only use the time to failure or reliability, R(t) information for managing your reliability program.
Hope that helps.
Cheers,
Fred

Again, was that the appropriate response? Did I miss something?

Someone That Wants to Learn More

The comment:
Hi, I came across your “No MTBF” website on the internet, and would like to connect to your group, to learn more from experts and professionals in the field of Reliability Engineering. Thank You & Best Regards,
My response:
Hi … , you may also enjoy accendoreliability.com which has many more articles, webinars, and podcasts on a wide range of reliability engineering topics. cheers, Fred
Oh, and just received this comment:
Thanks Fred! Thank you for all the great information you always give us!
My immediate response to both of these was a broad smile. Glad to help and appreciate the kind words that you provide.

What Questions do You Have?

Finally, as I’ve stated many times, if you have a question or comment, just let me know and I’ll try to respond in a meaningful and helpful way.
Understanding reliability is a lifelong endeavor. Asking questions is a natural part of what we should be doing. Also, use the comments section below to show how you would respond to the above questions.

Filed Under: Articles, NoMTBF

« What is Robust Design?
6 Tips for Becoming an Engineering Subject Matter Expert »

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

[popup type="" link_text="Get Weekly Email Updates" link_class="button" ]

[/popup]

The Accendo Reliablity logo of a sun face in circuit

Please login to have full access.




Lost Password? Click here to have it emailed to you.

Not already a member? It's free and takes only a moment to create an account with your email only.

Join

Your membership brings you all these free resources:

  • Live, monthly reliability webinars & recordings
  • eBooks: Finding Value and Reliability Maturity
  • How To articles & insights
  • Podcasts & additional information within podcast show notes
  • Podcast suggestion box to send us a question or topic for a future episode
  • Course (some with a fee)
  • Largest reliability events calendar
  • Course on a range of topics - coming soon
  • Master reliability classes - coming soon
  • Basic tutorial articles - coming soon
  • With more in the works just for members
Speaking of Reliability podcast logo

Subscribe and enjoy every episode

RSS
iTunes
Stitcher

Join Accendo

Receive information and updates about podcasts and many other resources offered by Accendo Reliability by becoming a member.

It’s free and only takes a minute.

Join Today

Dare to Know podcast logo

Subscribe and enjoy every episode

RSS
iTunes
Stitcher

Join Accendo

Receive information and updates about podcasts and many other resources offered by Accendo Reliability by becoming a member.

It’s free and only takes a minute.

Join Today

Accendo Reliability Webinar Series podcast logo

Subscribe and enjoy every episode

RSS
iTunes
Stitcher

Join Accendo

Receive information and updates about podcasts and many other resources offered by Accendo Reliability by becoming a member.

It’s free and only takes a minute.

Join Today

Recent Articles

  • test
  • test
  • test
  • Your Most Important Business Equation
  • Your Suppliers Can Be a Risk to Your Project

© 2025 FMS Reliability · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · Cookies Policy