Accendo Reliability

Your Reliability Engineering Professional Development Site

  • Home
  • About
    • Contributors
  • Reliability.fm
    • Speaking Of Reliability
    • Rooted in Reliability: The Plant Performance Podcast
    • Quality during Design
    • Way of the Quality Warrior
    • Critical Talks
    • Dare to Know
    • Maintenance Disrupted
    • Metal Conversations
    • The Leadership Connection
    • Practical Reliability Podcast
    • Reliability Matters
    • Reliability it Matters
    • Maintenance Mavericks Podcast
    • Women in Maintenance
    • Accendo Reliability Webinar Series
  • Articles
    • CRE Preparation Notes
    • on Leadership & Career
      • Advanced Engineering Culture
      • Engineering Leadership
      • Managing in the 2000s
      • Product Development and Process Improvement
    • on Maintenance Reliability
      • Aasan Asset Management
      • AI & Predictive Maintenance
      • Asset Management in the Mining Industry
      • CMMS and Reliability
      • Conscious Asset
      • EAM & CMMS
      • Everyday RCM
      • History of Maintenance Management
      • Life Cycle Asset Management
      • Maintenance and Reliability
      • Maintenance Management
      • Plant Maintenance
      • Process Plant Reliability Engineering
      • ReliabilityXperience
      • RCM Blitz®
      • Rob’s Reliability Project
      • The Intelligent Transformer Blog
      • The People Side of Maintenance
      • The Reliability Mindset
    • on Product Reliability
      • Accelerated Reliability
      • Achieving the Benefits of Reliability
      • Apex Ridge
      • Metals Engineering and Product Reliability
      • Musings on Reliability and Maintenance Topics
      • Product Validation
      • Reliability Engineering Insights
      • Reliability in Emerging Technology
    • on Risk & Safety
      • CERM® Risk Insights
      • Equipment Risk and Reliability in Downhole Applications
      • Operational Risk Process Safety
    • on Systems Thinking
      • Communicating with FINESSE
      • The RCA
    • on Tools & Techniques
      • Big Data & Analytics
      • Experimental Design for NPD
      • Innovative Thinking in Reliability and Durability
      • Inside and Beyond HALT
      • Inside FMEA
      • Integral Concepts
      • Learning from Failures
      • Progress in Field Reliability?
      • R for Engineering
      • Reliability Engineering Using Python
      • Reliability Reflections
      • Testing 1 2 3
      • The Manufacturing Academy
  • eBooks
  • Resources
    • Accendo Authors
    • FMEA Resources
    • Feed Forward Publications
    • Openings
    • Books
    • Webinars
    • Journals
    • Higher Education
    • Podcasts
  • Courses
    • 14 Ways to Acquire Reliability Engineering Knowledge
    • Reliability Analysis Methods online course
    • Measurement System Assessment
    • SPC-Process Capability Course
    • Design of Experiments
    • Foundations of RCM online course
    • Quality during Design Journey
    • Reliability Engineering Statistics
    • Quality Engineering Statistics
    • An Introduction to Reliability Engineering
    • Reliability Engineering for Heavy Industry
    • An Introduction to Quality Engineering
    • Process Capability Analysis course
    • Root Cause Analysis and the 8D Corrective Action Process course
    • Return on Investment online course
    • CRE Preparation Online Course
    • Quondam Courses
  • Webinars
    • Upcoming Live Events
  • Calendar
    • Call for Papers Listing
    • Upcoming Webinars
    • Webinar Calendar
  • Login
    • Member Home

by Fred Schenkelberg 1 Comment

Nelson Funnel Experiment

Nelson Funnel Experiment

Dr. Nelson created a simple experiment to illustrate the effect of meddling with a stable process. (Dr. Deming did something similar)

While the intent of making small changes to a process may be to make improvements, these perturbations generally increase the variation of the results.

To improve a process requires understanding the source of the variation and often controlled experiments to identify process improvements.

It is too easy to simply alter a process to ‘try something’ or to appear to be working on making improvements. Equipment operators often ‘tweak’ the process with the intent to improve yield or throughput. When these adjustments are made without effective feedback system they generally simply increase the variation and chance of failures.

The Nelson funnel is simple apparatus. It has a moveable funnel suspended over a grid. When a ball is dropped through the funnel it strikes the table and leaves a mark. If we drop 100 balls without moving anything we expect and will see a fairly tight group of strike marks.

Nelsons-funnel-stable

This group of marks shows the common cause variation of the system.

The balls in the experiment have slightly different diameters, coefficients of friction and interactions with the funnel. Likewise, the funnel may not remain perfectly still during the interaction with a ball or between ball drops. We would need to chance the system by moving the funnel closer to the target, exploring better funnel materials and alignment systems, and exploring a way to reduce the variability of the balls.

Instead, if we meddle with the process we generally increase the variation.

For example, if we observe the first ball struck it is a little to the right of the target, we may believe we can improve the aim by moving the funnel a little to the left. There is a 50% chance that the next drop would have been naturally to the left of the target, so adding a funnel movement would increase the miss to the left. Figure x.x shows the effect of these ‘tweaks’.

Nelsons-funnel-adjust

Another cause of this type of variation is managers tampering with worker performance without investing in systemic process changes. Exhorting employees to hit the target more often increases the incidence of meddling with the process.

Another way teams increase the variability of a system is to adjust for ‘windage’. Windage is the compensation for expected direction of variation. It tends to over compensate and broaden the variation.

Nelsons-funnel-windage

Examples of the windage adjustments include the US tax policy or corporate right-sizing efforts. For item creation windage adjustment occur when using uncorrelated readings to make adjustments for a lot of material, for example.

One more example of increase variation is drift.

Nelsons-funnel-drift

This occurs when one operator trains the next operator, who then trains the next, and so on. Another source is not correcting for wear or accumulation often due to ineffective feedback of the process performance.


 

Related:

Special and Common Causes of Process Variation (article)

Process Capability (article)

Statistical Process Control Overview (article)

 

Filed Under: Articles, CRE Preparation Notes, Probability and Statistics for Reliability Tagged With: Statistical Process control (SPC) and process capability

About Fred Schenkelberg

I am the reliability expert at FMS Reliability, a reliability engineering and management consulting firm I founded in 2004. I left Hewlett Packard (HP)’s Reliability Team, where I helped create a culture of reliability across the corporation, to assist other organizations.

« Recent CRE exam date
Time to move on from MTBF »

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CRE Preparation Notes

Article by Fred Schenkelberg

Join Accendo

Join our members-only community for full access to exclusive eBooks, webinars, training, and more.

It’s free and only takes a minute.

Get Full Site Access

Not ready to join?
Stay current on new articles, podcasts, webinars, courses and more added to the Accendo Reliability website each week.
No membership required to subscribe.

[popup type="" link_text="Get Weekly Email Updates" link_class="button" ]

[/popup]

  • CRE Preparation Notes
  • CRE Prep
  • Reliability Management
  • Probability and Statistics for Reliability
  • Reliability in Design and Development
  • Reliability Modeling and Predictions
  • Reliability Testing
  • Maintainability and Availability
  • Data Collection and Use

© 2025 FMS Reliability · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · Cookies Policy